Wow, so glad to hear you found out before sending some money. Did you go and see him in person before agreeing to purchase? I always try to go and see the horse, or have someone I know who lives close by the horse(s) I'm interested in, before buying- just in case. And when I do purchase, or give the buyer a downpayment- I request a reciept- ALWAYS. Even just a scribbled, handwritten one that says I officially put the cash down for specified horse.
How much were they asking for the fake Lewis? If you don't mind me asking...

.